Are there guide lines to consider?
If your fluid waste stream is of higher pressures, lower flows and/or higher viscosities a peristaltic pump is the best choice.
When dealing with lower pressures, higher flows and lower viscosities up to 3000 cst a screw centrifugal is the better one.
Sometimes less is more
Sometimes less is more: when using a peristaltic you are using less water, having less damage and less pollution but you get more pump value for money. By using a peristaltic or a screw centrifugal pump.
A screw centrifugal pump means also less: low initial purchase cost, less maintenance cost and less power consumption and at the same time offers many mores: to mention only a few: very high efficiency, higher flow, clog free operation.